A wasted Life?
At the end of his long and productive life, the naturalist Charles Darwin confessed in his autobiography that he had wholly wasted his adult life (and aspects of his humanity) pursuing scientific studies.
It had turned his mind into a mere filtering system, weeding out romance, imagination, prejudices, emotions, fancy, preconceptions, sympathies, dreams, personal madnesses and eccentricities. In other words, it had eliminated all that was human in him. What remained was an empty shell, a kind of machine, an automaton that consumed endless information.
‘My mind has changed during the last twenty or thirty years… My mind seems to have become a kind of machine for grinding general laws out of large collections of facts…”
‘If I had to live my life again I would have made a rule to read some poetry and listen to some music … The loss of these tastes is a loss of happiness, and may possibly be injurious to the intellect, and more probably to the moral character, by enfeebling the emotional part of our nature.’ (The Autobiography of Charles Darwin, 1809-1882, public domain e-book, pp.138-139)
Years before him, Descartes had divided the world into a measureable, corporeal res extensa (matter) on the one hand, and a res cogitans (soul/mind that did not follow the laws of matter) on the other. And scientists had followed Descartes’ lead ever after.
The Loss of Self
As a scientist, Darwin had become a kind of ascetic Desert Father, one who (of necessity) had purged himself of all passions, of all ego, lusts, ambitions, joys and fears. Within his heart there was no room for Darwin, only for the “Objective Consciousness”. He had become an observer, an alien before that which he was observing. He had carved up his world into an observer (an empty space rich in knowledge), and an external world from which he was independent, and for which he must have no sympathy. The knowledge obtained was said to be “beautiful” if it could be tidied up, classified and pigeon-holed. Darwin excelled at this.
By his own admission, this practice had produced a kind of hubris in him:
‘I think that I am superior to the common run of men in noticing things which easily escape attention, and in observing them carefully.’
But years of such scientific practice had turned him into something less than human. At the very end of his life he longed for Poetry and Music and Art. But it was too late; his mind was set in amber.
“Now for many years I cannot endure to read a line of poetry… I have also almost lost any taste for pictures or music“.
Objectivity alienates us from nature. It creates a relationship with Nature based on power and manipulation.
The Problem with Objectivity
Quantum Mechanics put an end to the “objective observer” once and for all. It validated what poets and mystics had long maintained: that it was impossible to separate the observer from the observed (Coleridge’s chameleon which changed in the shadow of the scientist who leaned over to examine it). The observer is intimately involved in all that he observes. He is an active participant in recreating the reality about and within him.
The tragedy for Darwin was one faced by many individuals nearing the end of their lives: regret at not having lived life fully, and sadness for having squandered precious time on pursuits that were financially lucrative, but in the end not important. The elimination of Art, Music and Poetry from Darwin’s life life was not only a “loss of happiness” but also “injurious to the intellect and more probably to the moral character” as well.
“Poetry is the primary activity of the human mind. Man, before he has arrived at the stage of forming universals forms imaginary ideas, before he can articulate he sings, before speaking in prose he speaks in verse, before using technical terms, he uses metaphors“
( Giambattista Vico (1688-1744) Author of Scienza Vuova)
RJ Antolak